The Challenges and Failure of a Doctor’s Attempt to Open a Medical Practice


Dr. John Doe, a board-certified internist with ten years of experience working in various hospital settings, decided to open his own medical practice in a suburban area. Driven by a desire for autonomy and the vision of providing personalized patient care, Dr. Doe believed that his experience and patient rapport would ensure a successful transition to private practice.

Initial Planning and Setup

Dr. Doe began the journey by conducting preliminary market research, which indicated a demand for primary care services in his chosen location. He secured a loan to cover startup costs, including leasing a facility, purchasing medical equipment, and hiring staff. The practice was named “Doe Family Medicine.”

  • Location Selection: A suburban area with limited primary care providers.
  • Financing: A business loan of $250,000 to cover initial costs.
  • Staffing: Hired a front office receptionist, a medical assistant, and a part-time practice manager.
  • Marketing: Basic marketing strategies, including local advertisements, a website, and social media presence.

Key Challenges and Issues

Despite Dr. Doe’s enthusiasm and careful planning, several challenges quickly emerged:

  • Regulatory and Administrative Burdens: Dr. Doe underestimated the complexity and time-consuming nature of regulatory compliance, including credentialing with insurance companies, acquiring necessary licenses, and adhering to healthcare compliance regulations. This delayed the practice’s opening by several months.
  • Financial Mismanagement: Initial capital was rapidly depleted due to unforeseen expenses, such as higher-than-expected renovation costs, capital equipment expenses and legal fees. Additionally, patient volumes were lower than anticipated, leading to insufficient revenue to cover operational costs.
  • Ineffective Marketing: Dr. Doe’s marketing efforts failed to attract a sufficient number of new patients. His limited experience in business and marketing, coupled with a modest budget, resulted in ineffective outreach.
  • Competition and Market Saturation: The market research conducted was not thorough enough to identify emerging competitors. Shortly after opening, a well-established medical group expanded its services in the area, drawing potential patients away from Dr. Doe’s practice.
  • Operational Inefficiencies: The practice faced significant operational inefficiencies. The office manager struggled with billing and coding, leading to delays and errors in insurance reimbursements. This exacerbated cash flow problems.
  • Work-Life Balance: The demands of managing the practice and providing patient care were overwhelming for Dr. Doe. The lack of a work-life balance led to burnout, affecting his decision-making and overall management of the practice.
Medical Office Closed

Dr. Doe’s experience highlights several critical lessons for physicians considering opening their own practice:

  1. Thorough Market Research: The need to conduct comprehensive market research to understand demand, competition, and patient demographics is critical.  Access to vendors and databases to drill down on key aspects of markets under consideration is crucial.
  2. Financial Planning and Management: Securing adequate funding and maintaining strict financial oversight is necessary to manage cash flow.  This starts with a thorough pro forma (financial projections) that takes into consideration a myriad of expenses not only for the first few months, illustrating burn rates, but for the first few years.  Additionally, knowledge of patient acquisition and “ramp up” times of patient volume can only be extrapolated with experience and understanding of the specialty.  Lastly, access to a number of different lenders promotes competition for the best loan rates and terms.
  3. Marketing and Outreach: Developing a robust marketing plan with firms that ONLY work with medical practices is a must.  These firms are acutely aware of the nuances that are specific to medical marketing.  In addition, in some cases, it is equally important to consider print media depending on the specific practice location.
  4. Operational Expertise: Ensuring competent administrative and operational support, including expertise in billing, coding, and regulatory compliance requires experience.  Placing job ads, interviewing and reference checking also takes a lot of time and effort.
  5. Work-Life Balance: Planning for a sustainable work-life balance to prevent burnout while maintaining effective practice management needs guidance.  

Dr. Doe’s attempt to open a medical practice serves as a cautionary tale about the complexities and challenges of transitioning from an employed arrangement to private practice ownership. Despite his clinical expertise and dedication, the lack of comprehensive business acumen, financial oversight, and effective marketing ultimately led to the failure of Doe Family Medicine. Future physicians can learn from this case by recognizing the importance of thorough preparation, professional support by Doctors Management, and realistic expectations in the journey to practice ownership.

Pen pointing at a neurology brain scan.
Previous Case Study
Neurologist Leaves the Grind Behind to Work Less & Make More | Practice Startup
Dark blue background, mixed with light blue and orange.

Put your practice on the right track so you can focus on your patients

Schedule Your Free Consultation
Call Us (800) 635-4040